The Worst Home Health Care Agencies in New Castle, Indiana

Updated as of April 01, 2024

As the US population grows older, more of us are going to need some kind of help with our daily routines or to recover from specific afflictions. Much of that care will take place outside of a hospital or residential care setting. We believe that one of the best ways to live longer or to recover faster is through health care services that are delivered in your home.

There are many benefits to receiving health care at home. First, it is often more convenient for patients, since they don’t have to travel to a facility. Second, it can be less expensive than receiving care in a hospital or other setting. Third, patients may feel more comfortable and relaxed in their own homes. Home treatment has been shown to lead to faster recoveries and better overall outcomes than similar treatments administered in a hospital or group home setting.

Home Health Care Agencies in New Castle, Indiana

There are 98 home health care companies registered with the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid that serve the Highland, Arkansas area. Because home health care agencies visit your home, you may be in an agency's service area even if they do not have an office in Highland.

The list below shows the worst home health care agencies in the market ranked by their overall 5-star quality of care rating. (Click here to see the best home health care agencies in New Castle, Indiana.)

Name 5-Star Quality of Care Rating
UNITED HEARTS HEALTH CARE
3515 SPRINGDALE ROAD
CINCINNATI, OH 45251
1.5:
INDEPENDENT HOME HEALTH CARE LLC
7318 CROSSING PLACE
FISHERS, IN 46038
1.5:
SCOTT'S HOME HEALTHCARE LLC
3208 S. LAFOUNTAIN STREET
KOKOMO, IN 46902
1.5:
OASIS HOME HEALTH AGENCY LLC
8250 WINTON ROAD SUITE 103
CINCINNATI, OH 45231
1.5:
UNITED HOME HEALTH CARE LLC
4535 N WHEELING AVE
MUNCIE, IN 47304
2:
PURPOSECARE OF INDIANA
5455 HARRISON PARK LA
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46216
2:
PURE HOME HEALTH CARE LLC
777 E MAIN STREET, SUITE 211
WESTFIELD, IN 46074
2:
HEALING HANDS HOME HEALTH LLC
216 E 9TH STREET
ANDERSON, IN 46016
2:
REMEDY HOME HEALTHCARE, LLC
813 MAIN ST, SUITE A
BROOKVILLE, IN 47012
2:
PREMIER HOME HEALTH CARE LLC
504 N BRADNER AVE
MARION, IN 46952
2:
ALPHA THERAPEUTICS, PC
8424 E 12 MILE, SUITE B
WARREN, MI 48093
2.5:
HOME HEALTH ANGELS LLC
117 N MAIN ST PO BOX 283
WINCHESTER, IN 47394
2.5:
INTERIM HEALTHCARE OF INDIANAPOLIS
373 MERIDIAN PARKE LANE, SUITE A-1
GREENWOOD, IN 46142
2.5:
BEST CHOICE HOME CARE
5701 ELMWOOD AVE STE N
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46203
2.5:
HARMONYCARES HOME HEALTH
9100 PURDUE ROAD, STE 110
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46268
2.5:
INDIANA UNIVERSITY HEALTH HOME CARE
950 N MERIDIAN ST STE 700
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204
2.5:
HCMH HOME CARE
798 N 16TH STREET
NEW CASTLE, IN 47362
2.5:
CAREGIVERS INC
3536 WASHINGTON BLVD
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46205
2.5:
HOME SERVICES UNLIMITED INC
7750 N MICHIGAN RD
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46268
2.5:
MAJESTIC HOME HEALTH LLC
777 E MAIN STREET, SUITE 211
WESTFIELD, IN 46074
2.5:
QUALITY LIFE SERVICES, LLC
1251 NILLES ROAD, SUITE 3
FAIRFIELD, OH 45014
2.5:
CARING FIRST HOME HEALTH LLC
28441 STATE ROUTE 1
W HARRISON, IN 47060
2.5:
TENDERCARE HOME HEALTH SERVICES INC
6308 RUCKER RD SUITE D
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46220
2.5:
LARRIS-IFY HOME CARE
5445 LAFAYETTE ROAD
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46254
2.5:
FRANCISCAN VNS HOME CARE, INC
1300 ALBANY STREET
BEECH GROVE, IN 46107
3:
ELITE HOME REHAB AND HEALTHCARE CORP
580 EAST CARMEL DRIVE, SUITE 208
CARMEL, IN 46032
3:
PREFERRED HOME HEALTH CARE, INC
6920 PARKDALE PLACE, SUITE 110
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46254
3:
PREBLE HOME HEALTH SERVICES
1673 NORTH BARRON STREET
EATON, OH 45320
3:
HERITAGE HOME HEALTH SERVICES LLC
429 E. VERMONT ST, SUITE 300
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46202
3:
ABILITY HOME HEALTH LLC
4555 NORTHWESTERN DR STE 1A
ZIONSVILLE, IN 46077
3:
MERCER HEALTH HOME CARE
909 EAST WAYNE STREET, SUITE 126
CELINA, OH 45822
3:
HEARTS WITH INTEGRITY
603 E NORTH STREET
HARTFORD CITY, IN 47348
3:
INDIANA MASONIC HOME, INC
690 S STATE STREET
FRANKLIN, IN 46131
3.5:
COMPREHENSIVE HEALTH NETWORK
5420 STATE ROUTE 571
GREENVILLE, OH 45331
3.5:
SUBURBAN HOME HEALTH LLC
14297 BERGEN BOULEVARD STE 250
NOBLESVILLE, IN 46060
3.5:
PREMIER HOMECARE OF INDIANA
8455 KEYSTONE CROSSING
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46240
3.5:
INDIANA HOMECARE NETWORK
1400 E MCGALLIARD RD
MUNCIE, IN 47303
3.5:
CENTERWELL HOME HEALTH
400 N HIGH STREET SUITE 202
MUNCIE, IN 47305
4:
ASCENSION AT HOME
600 CORPORATION DRIVE STE 104
PENDLETON, IN 46064
4:
GOLDEN AGE HOME HEALTH CARE LLC
5080 NORTH STATE ROAD 135, SUITE F
BARGERSVILLE, IN 46106
4:
ANGELS OF MERCY HOMECARE
1140 W JEFFERSON STREET STE B
FRANKLIN, IN 46131
4:
ASCENSION AT HOME
8909 PURDUE ROAD SUITE 107
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46268
4:
ADORATION HOME HEALTH
11595 MERIDAN ST STE 515
CARMEL, IN 46032
4:
REID HOME HEALTH
200 NORTH BARRON STREET, SUITE A
EATON, OH 45320
4:
COMMUNITY HEALTH AT HOME LLC
8034 CASTLEWAY CT W STE 100
INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46250
4:
REID-ANC HOME CARE SERVICES LLC
2220 CHESTER BLVD
RICHMOND, IN 47374
4:
AMERICAN NURSING CARE INC
4550 MIDDLE RD STE C
COLUMBUS, IN 47203
4.5:
PHYSICIANS CHOICE INC
5130 PRINCETON GLENDALE ROAD
HAMILTON, OH 45011
4.5:
HOOSIER HOMECARE SERVICES LLC
614 EAST 53RD STREET
ANDERSON, IN 46013
4.5:
SELECT HOME HEALTH SERVICES LLC
650 E CARMEL DRIVE SUITE 400
CARMEL, IN 46032
4.5:

How are Home Health Care Agencies Rated?

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid ("CMS") generates two types of 5-star rating, the Quality of Patient Care Star Ratings and Patient Survey Star Ratings.

Quality of Patient Care Ratings are based on data compiled by CMS based on the percentage of patients whose conditions improve as a result of care provided by the agency. The general guidelines are that these measures should :

  • Apply to a substantial proportion of home health patients and have sufficient data to report for a majority of home health agencies.
  • Show a reasonable amount of variation among home health agencies and it should be possible for a home health agency to show improvement in performance.
  • Have high face validity and clinical relevance.
  • Be stable and not show substantial random variation over time.
  • Have changed over time based on the results of ongoing monitoring analyses, technical expert panel input, and stakeholder feedback.

Patient improvement is measured in the following ways:

  • Timely Initiation of Care
  • Improvement in Ambulation
  • Improvement in Bed Transferring
  • Improvement in Bathing
  • Improvement in Shortness of Breath
  • Improvement in Management of Oral Medications
  • Acute Care Hospitalization

CMS also regularly surveys home health care patients using The Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems (CAHPS®) Home Health Care Survey ("HHCAHPS”). Patients are asked to rate the home health care agency according the following:

  • Percent Of Patients Who Reported That Their Home Health Team Gave Care In A Professional Way
  • Percent Of Patients Who Reported That Their Home Health Team Communicated Well With Them
  • Percent Of Patients Who Reported That Their Home Health Team Discussed Medicines, Pain, And Home Safety With Them
  • Percent Of Patients Who Gave Their Home Health Agency A Rating Of 9 Or 10 On A Scale From 0 (lowest) To 10 (highest)
  • Percent Of Patients Who Reported YES, They Would Definitely Recommend The Home Health Agency To Friends And Family

Because CMS loves to generate 5-star ratings, there are also 5-star ratings related to each of these questions.

Other Lists of the Worst Home Health Care Agencies

The worst home health care agencies in Indiana

Major Cities in Indiana

Indianapolis, IN (best, worst) Fort Wayne, IN (best, worst)
South Bend, IN (best, worst) Evansville, IN (best, worst)
Lafayette, IN (best, worst) Elkhart, IN (best, worst)
Bloomington, IN (best, worst) Carmel, IN (best, worst)
Fishers, IN (best, worst) Terre Haute, IN (best, worst)
Muncie, IN (best, worst) Anderson, IN (best, worst)
Kokomo, IN (best, worst) Hammond, IN (best, worst)
Gary, IN (best, worst) Michigan City, IN (best, worst)
Noblesville, IN (best, worst) Columbus, IN (best, worst)
Greenwood, IN (best, worst) West Lafayette, IN (best, worst)